Showing posts with label Anna Politkovskaya. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Anna Politkovskaya. Show all posts

Wednesday, 13 June 2012

The Morning After


In the news...opposition leaders are called in for interrogation after raids on their homes and offices, while the head of the Investigative Committee threatens a journalist.

To those commentators who have been talking about Putin 2.0 and looking forward to the Russian President’s renewed approach to power, the events in Moscow over the last few days must come as an unpleasant set back. To me, they come as an expected shock, but a shock nonetheless. The raids against the opposition leaders conducted on Monday before the rally scheduled for Russia’s Independence Day on June 12th is, unfortunately, only part of the story. The scandal involving Novaya Gazeta’s Sergei Sokolov and the head of the Russian Investigative Committee Aleksandr Bystirkin exposes a much more sinister side of power in the country, in which free press is not only under pressure, but direct attack.

Today, the editor-in-chief of Novaya, Dmitri Muratov, published an open letter to Bystirkin, calling for guarantees of safety for his staff, following the publication by lifenews.ru website of the conversation between Sokolov and Bystirkin that allegedly took place on June 4 this year. In this short excerpt recoded by the journalist, he begins with an apology for his emotional accusation of Bystirkin’s patronage of a man responsible for destroying evidence concerning the deaths of twelve members of a criminal gang in November 2010. Instead of a two year sentence, the ex United Russia deputy was fined 150,000 roubles. According to Muratov, on a way back from a trip, Sokolov was driven to a forest, Bystirkin appearing shortly. The head of the IC dismissed the security officers and took Sokolov into the woods, expressing his dissatisfaction with Novaya Gazeta, including the activities of the murdered journalist Anna Politkovskaya. (Her own experience in Chechnya, when she was abducted by the Russian Federal Forces, driven to a secluded spot and put through a mock execution for her critical coverage of the Russian crimes against the Chechen population is well known. Her actual murder remains unsolved.) Bystirkin is heard saying that such accusations of affiliation with the mafia caused in the good old days. He then, allegedly, threatened not only Sokolov, but also his family, if the paper refused to publish a redress. Careful not to make a bad situation worse, Muratov claims that he believes that this was merely an emotional breakdown on the part of the official, and would like an apology so that both sides can get over the heated argument without any tragic consequences. Meanwhile, Sokolov and his family had left Russia, fearing for their safety.

Now, today is not 1993, and this is not some distant province of Russia. Aside of being the head of the Investigative Committee, Bystirkin holds a doctorate in law, and is a university professor with many distinguished publications to his name. He is a colonel- general of the judiciary, decorated with two state medals. He also studied with Putin. The corruption and crime in the law enforcement forces is nothing new – it even makes it on the pro-government Channel One news. But if this man, who is responsible for the highest law authority in the country, has the power to threaten an opponent, and then suggest, only half jokingly, that he himself will be in charge of the murder case, crosses all boundaries. No, let me correct myself: there is no more visible legal boundaries remaining. Amen. Suffices to say that today, five Echo Moscow journalists were detained outside the offices of the Investigative Committee before they even began the protest in support of Novaya’s position. They were sitting on the pavement, writing on the banners they brought alone, when they were led away by the police. Luckily, all five were released without charge. So far.

The situation surrounding the opposition figureheads has received coverage in the West, even provoking censure from the US State Department and the European Union. Here is why: on Monday morning the blogger Alexei Navalny and Ksenia Sobchak – an infamous It-girl turned avid anti-government protestor awoke to the sound of armed men knocking down their doors. Navalny wrote today that all electronic equipment was taken from his flat, including his children’s’ photo cameras and some old pagers he hadn’t used since 1994 and kept as a souvenir. The search continued the next day after Navalny spent six hours answering questions at the, you guessed it, Investigative Committee offices, in his RosPil office, which has been sealed until further notice. The blogger claims that his apartment door has been practically sawed in two. 

It probably doesn’t help his case that today, Navalny filed a formal complaint with the European Court of Justice regarding claim of 5.4 billion roubles government theft investigated by his team. In 2010, European Parliament agreed on sanctions that prohibited travel for Russian officials that were listed in the so-called Magnitsy File. (If you remember, the lawyer who alleged tax-fraud sanctioned by numerous Russian officials in 2007, died in police custody just days before the one year limit he could be held without trial expired.) In October 2011, a Moscow court ordered Navalny to pay 100,000 roubles to Vladelen Stepanov and his wife, both mentioned in the Magnitsky list, and to retract the video posted on the RosPil website with details of their crimes. Navalny’s countersuit was declined in December 2011. So this is his next step. Brave? I think so.

The situation with Ksenia would have been amusing, given her celebrity status, had it not had such sinister possible consequences. The ‘Russian Paris Hilton’ has been active in the Millions March movement that started in December, and apparently the search in her apartment was provoked by the fact that another opposition figure, Ilya Yashin, suspected of organising mass protests under Article 212 of the Russian Federal Law (maximum sentence of ten years, nonetheless), is living on the premises. The TV-presenter, still in her nightdress, watched fifteen armed men ransack her home. But what was aimed as an act of intimidation turned nasty when over a million Euros were found stuffed into 100 separate envelopes in the safe. Unable to produce a viable explanation for where she has gotten all this money from – her lawyer was not allowed onto the premises – Sobchak now faces an unfavourable scenario: either the money is hers – after all, her deceased father, Anatoly Sobchak, the powerful mayor of St. Petersburg who took Putin under his wing in the 1990s, was a very wealthy man. But tax evasion is prosecuted in Russia when needs be, and a criminal sentence can be brought if the offender refuses to pay the fine. What is worse, given the way the money was distributed, is that it could have been indeed meant as sponsorship of the protests, which would make her liable under Article 212. Ksenia has already been dismissed as a host for a popular MTV-style show the previous month, as she claims, for her political activity. Now, she has spent hours answering 56 questions along with Yashin and Navalny and the IC, her passport confiscated. And this is Putin’s goddaughter – keep that in mind.

The protests went on without them, regardless. Thousands of people came out into the streets of Moscow – as the political analyst Gleb Pavlovky thinks, at least 15-20% spurred by the raids against the opposition leaders. There were no clashes, and the dreaded OMON kept its distance, and even, according to a Moskovky Komsomolets journalist, was even polite. The mood in the crows was perceptively different from the previous ‘walks’ – more tense, more political. Sergei Udaltsov, who refused to show up for interrogation scheduled an hour before the start of the rallies, unveiled a united opposition Manifesto, in which he called again for the release of political prisoners, concrete political reform, parliamentary and presidential re-elections, adding that ‘Russia will be free!’ to mass cheers. Boris Nemtsov, writing in his blog, said that he could not have imagined that 22 years after he helped vote Russia’s Declaration of Independence into law, he would witness a search in his home and offices. Udaltsov eventually left to be interrogated, and his parents’ flat was searched, along with Navalny’s in-laws home, where his wife’s 85 year-old grandmother was frightened into a stutter by threats to break down the door she refused to open to strangers.

The acute feeling of a bad hangover one gets reading these stories is only part of this narrative. The excitement the country felt when Putin replaced the ever-drunk, slurring Boris Yeltsin is long over and there are no idealistic illusions left. But this arrogance, this disrespect for the Russian people is a hefty mistake. If the Tandem had listened to the opposition from the start, maybe showed some even pretend interest in their claims, maybe this storm would have blown over. But now, with such direct aggression and shameless, personal abuse of power, the people are getting angry. Parallels to Stalin’s 1937 purges are trending all over the internet. And the story where a corrupt government violates basic human rights – to freedom of expression, to a decent education, to minimum wages, to affordable healthcare, to a fair justice system and an ability to choose leaders – rarely ends well. For everybody.

Sunday, 18 October 2009

Crimes and Misdemeanours

In the news...Commander in Chief of the Russian airborne troops orders special forces units to hinder a police investigation into his private affairs.

Following the collapse of the Soviet Union and particularly Boris Yeltsin’s tipsy years in power, Russia’s young government has been trying to rough-hew the country’s tattered international image. The project may as well have been entitled ‘Keeping Up Appearances’, for the words ‘lawlessness’ and ‘impunity’ are still prevalent in Russia’s discourse. While President Medvedev’s smiling eyes may have lured part of the audience into a false sense of well-being and security, the events off camera leave one shuddering at the state of play. On September 21, 2009 it became public knowledge that the commander in chief of the Russian elite airborne troops, Lieutenant General Vladimir Shamanov, had ordered two paratrooper squads to interfere in an active police investigation for personal reasons.
Novaya Gazeta - Russia’s leading investigative newspaper, which lost four journalists to political assassinations since 2001 (including, famously, Anna Politkovskya) - published the complete audio files of phone conversations from August 18, 2009 between the general and a group of his subordinates in which he ordered two special forces units to dispatch to the Moscow factory of his son-in-law to prevent a police detective from entering the premises. The communications are full of urgency and impatience on the general’s behalf and - to their credit - nervousness and tension from his subordinates, spiced with outrageous swearing on both sides. It makes for an obscene soundtrack to Russia's injustice system.
What adds extra salt to the story is the fact that this was not just an ill-judged misdemeanour but a grave obstruction of justice. Alexei Hramushin, the young man in question, has been a member of a Moscow mafia ring and has recently become a fugitive wanted internationally for conspiracy to murder of a former business partner. When Gen. Shamanov found out that police investigators were headed towards Hramushin’s offices, he did what every family man would do - he placed a phone call. Clearly, the fact that being under oath to his country surpasses all other affiliations did not cross the good man’s mind when he shouted the ‘Fuck, go ahead!’ command.
Overriding federal law might seem a small offence to a man who has disregarded much more reputable parameters of international jurisdiction. In 2005, the European Court for Human Rights convicted the former commander of the Russian federal forces in Chechnya for the ‘massive use of indiscriminate weapons’. In 1999 Gen. Shamanov ordered heavy bombing of the Katyr-Yurt village, which was being used as a ‘safe zone’ for refugees without either warning or allowing for an exit route for civilians. His order to prevent refugees from leaving zones of conflict has been infamously disobeyed by other commanders in the region. Allegations of Shamanov’s troops both carrying out extra-judicial killings and failing to prevent them are also abundant. A close personal friend of the General - Colonel Yuri Budanov - was the first high-ranking Russian officer to be convicted for a brutal murder of a Chechen girl. Shamanov protested against all allegations and is suspected to have been instrumental - as Governor of the region where the trial was held - in Budanov’s premature release after only 8.5 years in prison. For all these extraordinary achievements, Gen. Shamanov was awarded the Hero of Russia - the country’s most honoured medal.
As if becoming Chechnya’s very own bogeyman was not enough Shamanov, as head of Ministry of Defence’s combat training command, made headlines last year when he expressed the need for Russian soldiers to be prepared to fight for territorial acquisitions in the oil-rich Arctic. His public persona wavering from the inhuman to the grotesque, in May 2009 he was, nevertheless, named commander in chief of the airborne troops - the pride and glory of the Russian army - an equivalent to the US Marines. One only has to imagine what tricks Gen. Shamanov turned for the government during the controversial counter-terrorist operation in Chechnya, and what cards he holds against Russia’s Commander in Chief to get his alcohol-swollen, monosyllabic self appointed to this position.
It is superfluous to mention that Russian authorities have closed the investigation into the Shamanov’s war crimes allegations, ‘having found no evidence of a crime’. It hardly comes as a surprise that after two shorts weeks the Ministry of Defence investigation committee announced that all charges against Shamanov’s abuse of power will be dropped due to the lack of corpus dilecti - or constituent elements of offence. According to the committee, Shamanov recalled the operation after he realised he had made a mistake. Due to the information ban placed on this story, there is no confirmation that it was indeed the case or of what exactly happened at the factory when, and if, the swat teams arrived.
It has been just over a year since President Medvedev stressed the ‘particular importance on the fundamental role of the law,’ stating that Russia ‘must ensure true respect for the law and overcome the legal nihilism that is such a serious hindrance to modern development’ (Time, Jun. 04, 2009). In the meantime, Gen. Shamanov has been reprimanded and apologised, but still remains in office, clearly not embarrassing the image-conscious government enough to be replaced. After all, having war criminals present at conference tables is a long-standing political perk. Thus, foreign leaders will have the opportunity - on the next visit to Moscow - to shake hands with the devil.