Showing posts with label Sergei Udaltsov. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sergei Udaltsov. Show all posts

Wednesday, 13 June 2012

The Morning After


In the news...opposition leaders are called in for interrogation after raids on their homes and offices, while the head of the Investigative Committee threatens a journalist.

To those commentators who have been talking about Putin 2.0 and looking forward to the Russian President’s renewed approach to power, the events in Moscow over the last few days must come as an unpleasant set back. To me, they come as an expected shock, but a shock nonetheless. The raids against the opposition leaders conducted on Monday before the rally scheduled for Russia’s Independence Day on June 12th is, unfortunately, only part of the story. The scandal involving Novaya Gazeta’s Sergei Sokolov and the head of the Russian Investigative Committee Aleksandr Bystirkin exposes a much more sinister side of power in the country, in which free press is not only under pressure, but direct attack.

Today, the editor-in-chief of Novaya, Dmitri Muratov, published an open letter to Bystirkin, calling for guarantees of safety for his staff, following the publication by lifenews.ru website of the conversation between Sokolov and Bystirkin that allegedly took place on June 4 this year. In this short excerpt recoded by the journalist, he begins with an apology for his emotional accusation of Bystirkin’s patronage of a man responsible for destroying evidence concerning the deaths of twelve members of a criminal gang in November 2010. Instead of a two year sentence, the ex United Russia deputy was fined 150,000 roubles. According to Muratov, on a way back from a trip, Sokolov was driven to a forest, Bystirkin appearing shortly. The head of the IC dismissed the security officers and took Sokolov into the woods, expressing his dissatisfaction with Novaya Gazeta, including the activities of the murdered journalist Anna Politkovskaya. (Her own experience in Chechnya, when she was abducted by the Russian Federal Forces, driven to a secluded spot and put through a mock execution for her critical coverage of the Russian crimes against the Chechen population is well known. Her actual murder remains unsolved.) Bystirkin is heard saying that such accusations of affiliation with the mafia caused in the good old days. He then, allegedly, threatened not only Sokolov, but also his family, if the paper refused to publish a redress. Careful not to make a bad situation worse, Muratov claims that he believes that this was merely an emotional breakdown on the part of the official, and would like an apology so that both sides can get over the heated argument without any tragic consequences. Meanwhile, Sokolov and his family had left Russia, fearing for their safety.

Now, today is not 1993, and this is not some distant province of Russia. Aside of being the head of the Investigative Committee, Bystirkin holds a doctorate in law, and is a university professor with many distinguished publications to his name. He is a colonel- general of the judiciary, decorated with two state medals. He also studied with Putin. The corruption and crime in the law enforcement forces is nothing new – it even makes it on the pro-government Channel One news. But if this man, who is responsible for the highest law authority in the country, has the power to threaten an opponent, and then suggest, only half jokingly, that he himself will be in charge of the murder case, crosses all boundaries. No, let me correct myself: there is no more visible legal boundaries remaining. Amen. Suffices to say that today, five Echo Moscow journalists were detained outside the offices of the Investigative Committee before they even began the protest in support of Novaya’s position. They were sitting on the pavement, writing on the banners they brought alone, when they were led away by the police. Luckily, all five were released without charge. So far.

The situation surrounding the opposition figureheads has received coverage in the West, even provoking censure from the US State Department and the European Union. Here is why: on Monday morning the blogger Alexei Navalny and Ksenia Sobchak – an infamous It-girl turned avid anti-government protestor awoke to the sound of armed men knocking down their doors. Navalny wrote today that all electronic equipment was taken from his flat, including his children’s’ photo cameras and some old pagers he hadn’t used since 1994 and kept as a souvenir. The search continued the next day after Navalny spent six hours answering questions at the, you guessed it, Investigative Committee offices, in his RosPil office, which has been sealed until further notice. The blogger claims that his apartment door has been practically sawed in two. 

It probably doesn’t help his case that today, Navalny filed a formal complaint with the European Court of Justice regarding claim of 5.4 billion roubles government theft investigated by his team. In 2010, European Parliament agreed on sanctions that prohibited travel for Russian officials that were listed in the so-called Magnitsy File. (If you remember, the lawyer who alleged tax-fraud sanctioned by numerous Russian officials in 2007, died in police custody just days before the one year limit he could be held without trial expired.) In October 2011, a Moscow court ordered Navalny to pay 100,000 roubles to Vladelen Stepanov and his wife, both mentioned in the Magnitsky list, and to retract the video posted on the RosPil website with details of their crimes. Navalny’s countersuit was declined in December 2011. So this is his next step. Brave? I think so.

The situation with Ksenia would have been amusing, given her celebrity status, had it not had such sinister possible consequences. The ‘Russian Paris Hilton’ has been active in the Millions March movement that started in December, and apparently the search in her apartment was provoked by the fact that another opposition figure, Ilya Yashin, suspected of organising mass protests under Article 212 of the Russian Federal Law (maximum sentence of ten years, nonetheless), is living on the premises. The TV-presenter, still in her nightdress, watched fifteen armed men ransack her home. But what was aimed as an act of intimidation turned nasty when over a million Euros were found stuffed into 100 separate envelopes in the safe. Unable to produce a viable explanation for where she has gotten all this money from – her lawyer was not allowed onto the premises – Sobchak now faces an unfavourable scenario: either the money is hers – after all, her deceased father, Anatoly Sobchak, the powerful mayor of St. Petersburg who took Putin under his wing in the 1990s, was a very wealthy man. But tax evasion is prosecuted in Russia when needs be, and a criminal sentence can be brought if the offender refuses to pay the fine. What is worse, given the way the money was distributed, is that it could have been indeed meant as sponsorship of the protests, which would make her liable under Article 212. Ksenia has already been dismissed as a host for a popular MTV-style show the previous month, as she claims, for her political activity. Now, she has spent hours answering 56 questions along with Yashin and Navalny and the IC, her passport confiscated. And this is Putin’s goddaughter – keep that in mind.

The protests went on without them, regardless. Thousands of people came out into the streets of Moscow – as the political analyst Gleb Pavlovky thinks, at least 15-20% spurred by the raids against the opposition leaders. There were no clashes, and the dreaded OMON kept its distance, and even, according to a Moskovky Komsomolets journalist, was even polite. The mood in the crows was perceptively different from the previous ‘walks’ – more tense, more political. Sergei Udaltsov, who refused to show up for interrogation scheduled an hour before the start of the rallies, unveiled a united opposition Manifesto, in which he called again for the release of political prisoners, concrete political reform, parliamentary and presidential re-elections, adding that ‘Russia will be free!’ to mass cheers. Boris Nemtsov, writing in his blog, said that he could not have imagined that 22 years after he helped vote Russia’s Declaration of Independence into law, he would witness a search in his home and offices. Udaltsov eventually left to be interrogated, and his parents’ flat was searched, along with Navalny’s in-laws home, where his wife’s 85 year-old grandmother was frightened into a stutter by threats to break down the door she refused to open to strangers.

The acute feeling of a bad hangover one gets reading these stories is only part of this narrative. The excitement the country felt when Putin replaced the ever-drunk, slurring Boris Yeltsin is long over and there are no idealistic illusions left. But this arrogance, this disrespect for the Russian people is a hefty mistake. If the Tandem had listened to the opposition from the start, maybe showed some even pretend interest in their claims, maybe this storm would have blown over. But now, with such direct aggression and shameless, personal abuse of power, the people are getting angry. Parallels to Stalin’s 1937 purges are trending all over the internet. And the story where a corrupt government violates basic human rights – to freedom of expression, to a decent education, to minimum wages, to affordable healthcare, to a fair justice system and an ability to choose leaders – rarely ends well. For everybody.

Sunday, 27 May 2012

Systems analysis


In the news...two opposition leaders are released from prison after 15 days, but might face up to two more years if found guilty of 'inciting mass disorder'.

In December 2011, Vladimir Putin told the press that his government welcomes non-extremist opposition and is open to dialogue. When a journalist suggested to get the leaders of the opposition together, however, the then Prime Minister retorted that the opposition is too varied and does not present a united political platform, and so negotiating with each group about its specific demands needs to be thought through. Putin was riding high after the United Russia party with which he is associated ‘won’ the Parliamentary election earlier in December, so he could afford to be dismissive. He also had a point. Since the first mass protests took off, following allegations of wide-spread ballot-stuffing in December, three key figures began to dominate the marches. Alexei Navalny, Sergei Udaltsov and Boris Nemtsov have, in the past six months of protests, spent enough time in prison for Amnesty International to take notice. All call for electoral and political reform, control over the actions of the government, release of political prisoners and new, open elections. Admirable goals, which united hundreds of thousands of people. But, taken separately, the three men’s politics are so disparate, it is difficult to imagine them at the same party together, let alone on a political stage.  

Responsible for the catchy epithet ‘party of crooks and thieves’, now recognised by more than 2/3 of the population, Alexei Navalny came to prominence after launching in December 2010 of his RosPil project, which literally translates as ‘sawing apart’ – a website that discloses corruption by public officials by analysing financial documents available online. The project became a mass phenomenon, earning Navalny 6th place in Time’s 100 most influential people of 2012 list. His approach is to tell it like it is and not take any prisoners, coupled with a background in law, make him for a formidable public figure. But aye, there is the rub.

In 2007, Navalny founded the ‘People’ movement, whose manifesto declares that Russia is facing a national catastrophe as the population ‘degrades and dies off’. To prevent this, the movement calls on national rehabilitation, freedom and justice, and asserts that the Russian people have earned their right to live in a democracy. But that is exactly the problem - the emphasis is on the ‘Russian’. Navalny’s ideal is that of a ‘nationalist democracy’, in which immigration policy is of paramount importance. When he talks about his nationalism, Navalny sounds very reasonable and convincing. He calls for assimilation of immigrants into the traditions and laws of Russia, and envisions it as a ‘bigger, more irrational and metaphysical Canada’. In his interviews, he is either purposely evasive, or he really believes that nationalist sentiments can be indeed have a ‘human face’. The problem jolts you in the face when, in answer to the question whether he agrees with the mission statement of the Movement Against Illegal Immigration (DPNI) – Russia’s answer to the English Defense League that was banned in 2011 as extremist – he says ‘Yes, why, is something wrong with it?’ Navalny may truly fool himself into believing that by attending the Russian March rallies where slogans like ‘Russia for Russians!’ are a staple, he can somehow make them, in his own words, ‘better’. But he occupies an unfavourable public position: the far right sees him as too moderate while the liberal opposition shuns his nationalistic views and currently sees no political future for him. A real shame for someone who managed, so forcefully, to grab the attention and admiration of the Russian public.

Sergei Udaltsov, for all his admirable fervour and resilience in face of multiple arrests, really wants to turn Russia into one giant kibbutz. In 2008, Udaltsov, also a lawyer, was elected onto the executive committee of the Left Front – a political movements whose main goal is the creation of socialism in Russia. The list of grievances is familiar: corruption, disintegration of culture, science, education, health, army and  the police. The way to overcome these problems is to combine public property with true ‘people-power’ – a political and production democracy. Lenin’s call was ‘Land to the people, factories to the workers!’ In the new version, ‘each worker is an owner, and each owner, a worker’. As a side note, the manifesto states that small private property will not be expropriated in this fight against global bourgeois capitalism (oh yes, you heard right) as it must prove itself in free economic competition with public property – whatever that means. The raison d’être of this movement, is, no more not less, to ‘accelerate the movement of history!’

In 2010, Udaltsov founded ROT-Front – United Russian Workers’ Front (a holler back to 1917, again), based largely on the policies of the Left Front and calling specifically for social justice and protection for all – and not just the rich and powerful. There is a call to share the oil and gas wealth with the population, to introduce a luxury tax and access of each individual to objective and accurate information that ‘precludes manipulation of public consciousness’. Just how the movement plans to convince the unconvinced, then, remains a technical mystery. But while the Left Front strictly excludes cooperation with any reactionary ideology – such as nationalism, fascism or liberalism, the ROT-front announces its readiness to coordinate with any political party whose goal is democracy. If you are thinking these view are too weird to warrant cooperation, don’t: Russia’s Communist Party’s presidential candidate Gennady Zuganov, endorsed by Udaltsov, came in second after Putin with 17% of the vote.

Boris Nemtsov, a professional politician who was groomed by Boris Yeltsin as a potential successor before Putin, is probably the better known and most credible face of the three. He has a solid record as a liberal, becoming the first governor of the new Russia in 1991, and is perhaps best remembered by the public for being doused with mango juice by the eccentric leader of the Liberal Democratic Party of Russia (which is neither liberal, nor democratic) during a debate in the 1990s. At the moment, he is one of the 39 committee members of the Solidarnost’ Movement, founded in 2008, whose main goal is to create a competitive economic and political system in the country. The organisation’s 300 Steps to Freedom programme is the most extensive and conclusive, offering a course of European-style development and free parliamentary elections with full access by all parties to the public information systems. In 2010, Nemtsov along with ex-Prime Minister Mikhail Kasyanov a number of young politicians founded the Party of People’s Liberty – PARNAS, but the ministry of Justice refused to register it, citing contradictions to federal law. If anything, this bureaucratic snub is an indicator of the potential threat of the movement – which attracts many prominent public figures – to the Putin regime.

So far, however, the only idea uniting the three main strands of the opposition is the call to liberalise the electoral system to allow for fair elections and political competition. But with the Kremlin’s power undiminished, and the protest rigour in decline, what the opposition needs is a better focus and a realistic political platform to offer to the electorate. There needs to be a plan for when the protest party is over. Political competition is a great thing, but when there are too many little Davids facing different sides of Goliath, the pebbles might hurt, but most likely will not kill the current corrupt system in place. And this dilemma is what gives Russia’s ‘non-systemic’ opposition a flailing double meaning.


Monday, 7 May 2012

Putin 3.0

In the news...Putin is sworn into his third term as President, amid continuing protests.

'Freedom – it is a unique feeling, which every person understands differently. You know, of course, there is always an element of objectivity in freedom, but generally it is just our own experiences’. If you are thinking I’m quoting Kant, you’re wrong. This is a line from President Medvedev’s last interview that he gave to five TV channels at once. He clearly wanted to be heard. Also, quite clearly, the irony of his philosophising was not lost on the thousands of protestors who came out on May 6 to contest the government’s usurpation of their freedom and right to vote - fairly, protest – peacefully, and think - differently. 

Again, it is hard to tell just how many people participated. The Moscow police place the figure at 8,000, while the organisers claim the ‘March of Millions’ as the protest was officially called, was not smaller than the election fraud rallies that gathered anywhere between 130,000 and 200,000. Ironically, (yes, again – there’s a lot of that today) the organisers filed for permission for 5,000 demonstrators with the city’s authorities. There have been detractions from the march, some from well-known figures, as they faced increasing futility of raging against the machine - so it is not just the government that likes to pretend.

Now, if the number of those in the opposition is debated, the number of police and special forces (OMON) shocked even the well-seasoned commentators. The police line blocking the way to the Kremlin looked like a fight scene straight out of Star Wars. Metal detectors blocked entrance to the main square where protests were meant to be held. However, everything was more or less peaceful when the march started. One journalist said a friend had brought his toddler along, as indeed have others, indicating that the plan was peaceful. Although it is still not quite clear how the clashes started – with protestors trying to break through the police line to get to the Kremlin, or with the police preventing the organisers from entering the main square – a large part of participants became isolated by the ‘Udarnik’ (‘hard-hitter’, nonetheless) cinema and things went awry.

There are numerous videos of police brutality, with OMON using batons to beat protestors unconscious, then leaving them on the ground. These images echo the footage that shocked the world in 2010, when Aleksandr Lukashenko – ‘Europe’s Last Dictator’, put down protests following a rigged election in Belarus. The government side (represented on Channel 1 news) claimed protestors were throwing bits of asphalt at them and, when these endangered the ‘passers-by’, they intervened. Maybe someone did actually decide to go for a walk in the middle of a rally, maybe…It was obvious that things got out of hand, with the media reporting tear gas being used – while state TV has OMON claiming it were fireworks lit by protestors to pass off as tear gas. Isn’t it a useful word, ‘allegedly’? In a moment of sweet revenge, the NTV van got showered with empty bottles and its tires were slashed – an answer to the shocking propaganda film ‘Anatomy of Protest’ the network aired right after the elections, ‘disclosing’ the protestors as fakes, ‘provocators’ etc. Having seen the film, and not condoning violence in the slightest, I think the slashed tires were totally deserved.

The Western media, even this morning, reported 120-150 detained protestors. I was wondering where they got the numbers from as even Channel 1 ran a figure of 250 last night, which it upgraded to 436 today. (The opposition claims 570 arrests). Twenty people were injured, along with twenty-nine police officers. (One of the OMON was interviewed on Channel 1, the reporter apologising for the man’s ‘slow speech’ as he had sustained a head injury. There seemed to be nothing wrong with the man. He was just struggling to string together a publishable sentence.) There have been no reports of deaths, aside from a photographer who fell to his death trying to get a better shot of the march. In an interview on TV Rain, Putin’s spokesman said the police were ‘too soft’. As Novaya Gezeta’s Yulia Latinina points out, people who have used less soft measures have had their foreign accounts frozen.

But, despite all these goings on, Putin was sworn into his third term this noon, in a ludicrously pompous ceremony performed for the first time at the Kremlin by no other but Ivan the Terrible himself. (I got this bit of trivia from Channel 1, so I apologise if it is misinformation, but I couldn’t resist pointing out the gaff.) There were Royal Guards, standing ovations, and a lot, a lot of gold. There were some very unexpected guests. For one, his wife, who Putin was widely rumoured to have divorced during his second term, and who has since been confined in wither a mental institution, a monastery, or both. (I remember catching the article about the divorce on the Washington Post website – the only official source I found carrying the information, only to discover it deleted an hour later.) His mistress – the former gymnast Alina Kabayeva, the mother of at least one of his children, was also photographed outside the Kremlin, though it is not clear from the official footage whether she was at the ceremony. Their affair, conducted in multi-million mansions throughout the country, is shrouded in secrecy. And though everyone expected Berlusconi to be there, Gorbachev was the real surprise. Does anyone remember him saying that Putin ‘castrated’ Russian democracy? Well, I don’t know what he was thinking. But he did not look happy, I can tell you that. The banquet that followed cost a $1million, according to Russia Today. The proceedings have been blessed by Archbishop of Russia Cyrill, who had been awarded a prestigious state medal last year – along with the head of the election committee Churov and the hated and corrupt head of the police, Nurgaliev. Pretty cosy, isn’t it?

And speaking of cosy: the first thing Putin did as President, aside from promising monetary benefits to World War II veterans (the elderly handful always comes in handy when public images need a lift) was to suggest Dmitry Medvedev for the position of Prime Minister. In case someone was wondering who might take over Putin’s old job, the new President did not even skip a beat on this one. And then, after yet another self-satisfied smirk, the President donned on his ice skates and scored the winning penalty in a hockey game against Russia’s Legends Team, a feat even less likely than Boris Johnson winning a cycle race against Team GB.

While the footage of the presidential journey to the Kremlin saw eerily deserted streets, there were more protests today throughout the city with around 300 detained and people were still being arrested while I was finishing researching this piece. Alexei Navalny, Boris Nemtsov and Sergei Udaltsov – the organisers of the March of Millions, were released today and are due to pay either a 1,000 roubles (20GBP) or spend 15 days in prison. I don’t know, what would you do?

A number of opposition media, such as TV Rain and Slon.ru reported hacking attempts to bring down their sites yesterday. Today, while researching, the Echo Moscow website was suspended. Meanwhile, Sunday saw pro-Putin rallies as well as the dress rehearsal of the May 9 Victory Day parade, with the usually impressive show of military force. The way things are going, the administration should have scheduled the inauguration for the 9th as well – to celebrate the government’s victory over freedom. But maybe that’s too subjective of me to say.